The 4 Different Types of Stretching: Compare and Contrast

Today, let’s talk about the 4 different types of stretching. Yes, the thing you avoid after every workout session because it doesn’t seem too important or it causes a level of discomfort you would rather not experience…again.

Admittedly, stretching isn’t the most popular aspect of fitness, but it’s a crucial one. Because who doesn’t want to be more flexible and minimize your risk of pulling another hamstring?

Joseph Pilates (yes, THAT Pilates) once said, “You are only as young as your spine is flexible”. We assume that applies to the entire body and not just the spine.

No matter your current fitness level, whether that be a seasoned athlete or just starting on your fitness journey, incorporating stretching into your routine is a must! Trust us, your body will thank you.

Let’s take a closer look at the four most common forms of stretching: static stretching, passive stretching, ballistic stretching, and PNF stretching.

What is Static Stretching?

Static stretching is the most common form of stretching and one that most are familiar with. Performing a static stretch involves holding a stretched position for a period of time, typically 20-30 seconds. It’s the “reach down and touch your toes” type stretch.

The aim of a static hold is to increase flexibility and improve range of motion in the muscles being stretched. When performing a static stretch, it’s advisable to hold the stretch in a comfortable position, without bouncing or forcing the stretch.

Pros and cons of static stretching:

Pros:

• Easy to perform
• Can be done anywhere
• Helps to increase flexibility and range of motion
• Improves posture
• Reduces muscle soreness

Cons:

• Can be time-consuming
• Can be uncomfortable
• Can be difficult to hold a stretch for the recommended time
• Not effective for warm-up purposes

What is Passive Stretching?

Passive stretching is a type of stretching that involves using external force to hold the stretch. This could be from a partner, a prop like a strap or a wall, or even gravity. Passive stretching is often used as a warm-up or cool-down technique, as it helps to relax the muscles and reduce the risk of injury. It’s also a good option for those who are unable to perform the stretch on their own, as the external force allows for a deeper stretch.

Benefits of passive stretching:

• Increases flexibility and range of motion
• Helps to reduce muscle soreness
• Relaxes the body and mind
• Can be performed without the need for a partner

What is Ballistic Stretching?

A ballistic stretch is a type of stretching in which a body part is subjected to momentum in an effort to increase range of motion. This type of stretching involves using the body’s momentum to force a joint beyond its normal range of motion.

A ballistic stretch is performed by bouncing or swinging the body part rapidly and repeatedly. This type of stretching can be dangerous, as the rapid and uncontrolled motion can put excessive force on muscles, tendons, and ligaments, potentially causing injury.

Dangers of ballistic stretching:

• Can cause muscle strain or tear
• Can lead to overstretching
• Can increase the risk of injury

What is Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) Stretching?

Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) stretching is a type of stretching that uses the concept of reciprocal inhibition, where the contraction of one muscle group helps to relax and stretch another muscle group. PNF stretching is considered one of the most effective stretching techniques for increasing range of motion and flexibility.

To increase ROM, all types of stretching are effective, although PNF-type stretching may be more effective for immediate gains.

National Library of Medicine

Pros and cons of PNF stretching:

Pros:

• Increases flexibility and range of motion
• Improves muscular endurance and strength
• Enhances athletic performance
• Reduces the risk of injury

Cons:

• Requires a partner
• Can be uncomfortable
• May take longer to perform
• Can be difficult to perform on your own

Compare and Contrast: Static vs Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) Stretching

Static stretching and PNF (Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation) stretching are two of the best techniques used to increase flexibility. The main difference between them is how the stretching is performed:

Static stretching: Involves holding a stretched muscle in a still position for an extended period of time, typically 15-30 seconds.

PNF stretching: Involves combining passive stretching with muscle contractions. The muscle being stretched is first passively stretched, then contracted isometrically against resistance for 6-10 seconds, followed by a passive stretch held for 20-30 seconds.

PNF stretching is thought to be more effective in increasing flexibility compared to static stretching, but it is also more complex and requires a partner or equipment to perform.

Pre and Post Workout Stretching Example

Here is a sample stretching routine that combines both passive and static stretching before and after a workout:

Pre-Workout Stretching Routine:

1. Dynamic Stretching: Warm up the body with 5-10 minutes of light aerobic activity such as jogging or jumping jacks, followed by a series of dynamic stretches that mimic the movement patterns of your workout. For example, if you’re going for a run, perform dynamic stretches such as leg swings, high knees, and ankle hops.
2. PNF Stretching: After the dynamic stretching, perform PNF stretching for the major muscle groups you will be using during your workout. For example, if you’re going for a weightlifting session, perform PNF stretching for the quadriceps, hamstrings, glutes, and lower back.
3. Static Stretching: Finish the pre-workout stretching routine with some light static stretching. Hold each stretch for 15-30 seconds, focusing on the major muscle groups used during your workout.

Post-Workout Stretching Routine:

1. Dynamic Stretching: After your workout, cool down with 5-10 minutes of light aerobic activity such as jogging or jumping jacks, followed by a series of dynamic stretches that mimic the movement patterns of your workout.
2. Passive Stretching: After the dynamic stretching, perform passive stretching for the major muscle groups you used during your workout. Hold each stretch for 30-60 seconds, focusing on relaxing the muscles and increasing flexibility.
3. Static Stretching: Finish the post-workout stretching routine with some longer static stretches. Hold each stretch for 30-60 seconds, focusing on the major muscle groups used during your workout.

Note: Do yourself a favor and always listen to your body and stop if you experience any pain or discomfort during stretching. Start off with a light stretching routine and gradually increase intensity and duration over time as your flexibility improves.

What is the best way to assess your own flexibility and how do you improve?

To assess your own flexibility, you can perform a series of tests to determine your range of motion in various joints. Some common flexibility tests include:

1. Sit and Reach Test: This test measures the flexibility of your hamstrings and lower back.
2. Shoulder Flexibility Test: This test measures the flexibility of your shoulder muscles and rotator cuff.
3. Hamstring Flexibility Test: This test measures the flexibility of your hamstrings.
4. Trunk Rotation Test: This test measures the flexibility of your torso and lower back.

How frequent should I stretch to see results?

We hate to be the bearers of bad news, but if you want to improve your flexibility, you have to consistently stretch on a regular basis.

“A lot of people don’t understand that stretching has to happen on a regular basis. It should be daily,” says David Nolan, a physical therapist at Harvard-affiliated Massachusetts General Hospital.

The frequency of stretching depends on your individual standing and goals. For general health and flexibility, you should stretch at least 2-3 times per week, with each stretching session lasting 10-15 minutes. If you have specific flexibility goals or are using stretching as part of a rehabilitation program, the recommendation is to stretch more frequently, such as daily or multiple times per day.

Additional Tips

If you’re unaware, you must stay hydrated, eat a balanced diet, and get adequate sleep to support healthy muscle tissue and overall flexibility. Incorporating yoga, Pilates, or other forms of functional movement into your fitness routine can also help improve your flexibility.

And don’t forget to listen to Numero Uno, yourself! Listen to what your body is telling you and avoid overstretching, which can lead to injury. Start with a light stretching routine and gradually increase intensity and duration over time as your flexibility improves.

Is there a difference between stretching and myofascial release?

Stretching and myofascial release are two distinct practices that serve different purposes, although they can complement each other.

Stretching: Stretching involves lengthening the muscles and tissues in a controlled manner to improve flexibility, reduce muscle tightness, and increase range of motion. Stretching can be performed dynamically (actively moving through a range of motion) or statically (holding a stretched position for a period of time).

Myofascial release: Myofascial release is a type of manual therapy that focuses on releasing tension and pain in the fascia (the connective tissue that covers the muscles). It is often performed using a foam roller, massage gun, or with the help of a therapist. The idea behind myofascial release is to apply pressure to tight or painful areas to break up adhesions (knots) in the fascia and promote healing.

While stretching and myofascial release serve different purposes, they can both help to improve flexibility and reduce muscle pain and tightness. Incorporating both practices into your fitness routine can help you to achieve optimal results.

Related Reading: The Chirp Wheel: Goodbye Back Pain